34 High Street, Sag Harbor Village, NY 11963

Fabled High Street Home with Water Views & Pool Permit


This 5 bedroom, 5 full bath designer-renovated home is sited at the top of High Street with views of the Harbor. On .20 acre, the 3200 s.f. +/- home, originally built in 1900 and fully redone in 2021, has a wonderful charm and pays tribute to its history but with modern, updated features and mechanicals. There are two bright and airy ensuite bedrooms on the second floor and three bedrooms and a full bath on the third floor. The chic eat-in chef's kitchen has top-of-the-line appliances and the glass-walled dining room, which was formerly a greenhouse at another time, is a magical place to entertain and dine. The main living space has a gas fireplace that makes it a particularly cozy place to hang on chilly evenings. There is a full unfinished basement.


Out back is an adorable rose-covered lofted studio fondly referred to as "La Rose de 34 Bis". This wonderful building has a full bath and is ideal for a potential office or pool house and has additional storage for bikes, chairs, etc. The back garden is fully privatized, has an outdoor shower and is beautifully landscaped. Permits are in place for a pool. The new owner of this wonderful piece of Sag Harbor's fabric could be in for most of the summer! Photographer: Eric Striffler


For more info, CLICK HERE.


3,200 Sq.Ft. LIVING AREA



Features & Amenities


  • total bedrooms5

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Living Area3,200 Sq.Ft.


  • Sales Price$3,500,000
View Virtual Tour

Work With Us

Whether working with first-time buyers or indulging the connoisseurs of life, representing a parcel of land or an estate, Compass Coastal offers exemplary time, care, attention and expertise to guide every client to find their way home.

Follow Us on Instagram