12 Amity Street, Sag Harbor Village, NY 11963

Renovated Historic Sag Harbor Village Gem


Nestled on historic Amity Street in the heart and spine of Sag Harbor Village between Suffolk and Madison, sits this 2021 completely gut-renovated 1840s house which was moved from the Village waterfront to its current location in 1880. Includes a charming house-wide covered front porch which opens to the main floor entry hallway and living room, a large eat-in kitchen/dining and a powder room. The second floor has 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths--ensuite primary bedroom overlooking the garden and barn and two other bedrooms that share a bath. There is a partially finished lower level which currently houses the laundry, but could easily be divided to create a media room or office or play space.


Sharing this .12 acre parcel is a beautiful historic barn that has been completely vetted by the Architecture Review Board--with review process completed and approved and building permits issued These permits are completely transferrable to a new owner. There may be room for a small plunge pool.



Features & Amenities

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold


  • Sales Price$2,750,000

Work With Us

Whether working with first-time buyers or indulging the connoisseurs of life, representing a parcel of land or an estate, Compass Coastal offers exemplary time, care, attention and expertise to guide every client to find their way home.

Follow Us on Instagram