17 Congdon Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Shelter Island


This meticulously restored 1960s cedar-lined modern architectural residence exudes the style of John Lautner and Frank Lloyd Wright. The nautilus-like curves create a comforting and cozy home, and the ambient aroma of the cedar interior is as relaxing as it is unique and memorable. The house has 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, a fireplace, and tons of built-in cabinetry-no space are left unused. Skylights and clerestory windows create that "inside/out-outside in" ambiance. The use of brick and stone throughout the interior further pays tribute to the modernist traditions so in-vogue these days. The waterside heated Gunite pool is the perfect foil for Lily Pond, just beyond. And a cabana completes the picture. The pond is part of the 2.3 acres and the property is currently 2 single and separate lots. There is a lovely outdoor dining/BBQ area with a firepit. A mowed path from the expansive yard to the pond front creates lovely vistas from the house and pool and makes for easy access for kayaking or canoeing. This is an all-seasons house-fantastic getaway in the summer and a warm and cozy wintertime retreat. And the private grounds are continually changing with the seasons. This property would be perfect for the City-dweller looking for space and a very chic place to hang one's hat. It could also be an ideal purchase for someone who owns a larger home on the South Fork or elsewhere on Shelter Island or on the North Fork that rents for the summer. They would have this very cool place to spend the summer while their other home is rented. There is room for expansion. All systems in the house are new. Located about 3 minutes from the South Ferry (Sag Harbor-bound) and about 6 minutes from the North Ferry (Greenport and North Fork-bound). Exclusively listed by CeeJackTeam. $1.695m.



1,450 Sq.Ft. LIVING AREA

2.3 Acres lot



Features & Amenities


  • total bedrooms2
  • Total bathrooms2
  • full bathrooms2
  • other interior Features Fireplace, Central AC

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Living Area1,450 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area2.3 Acres
  • MLS® ID351134
  • TypeResidential
  • YEAR BUILT1962


  • Sales Price$1,512,000

Work With Us

Whether working with first-time buyers or indulging the connoisseurs of life, representing a parcel of land or an estate, Compass Coastal offers exemplary time, care, attention and expertise to guide every client to find their way home.

Follow Us on Instagram